Grateful Isn't the Same as Gracious (And Our Kids Know the Difference)

Last week my daughter cried the entire 15 minutes of carpool, the scream-crying kind, where whatever you say bounces right off. It was so bad that instead of driving through the carpool line, I walked her in instead and sat with her outside her classroom for about 10 minutes until she was settled enough to walk in, and then I got back in the car with "f*ck, that was hard" ready to go.. because it was just that hard.

Instead I pulled up Justin Bieber's "Hallelujah," a song I've been listening to every morning before the house wakes up, one that moved me to tears recently and made me notice the ordinary stuff like, waking up, the rain, being able to brush my teeth, the people in my life and how I buzz right past them in my hurried state. And I said that I was grateful I got to catch her big feelings outside of the scream crying, and grateful I had the time to sit with her and hold space.

It's November, which means gratitude is about to be everywhere, and I want to talk about what actually builds it in kids.

Gracious and grateful are not the same thing

Most of the November pressure on parents is about graciousness.

Say thank you to Grandma.

Don't make a face at the sweater.

Gracious is the behavior, the manners, the receiving well. Grateful is what happens on the inside, and it's the part that actually does something for a kid.

Psychologist Andrea Hussong and her team at UNC Chapel Hill break gratitude into four parts: what we notice that we can be grateful for, how we think about why we were given it, how we feel about it, and what we do to show appreciation (Hussong et al., 2018). The thank-you is only the last step.


When do kids develop gratitude?

Older kids and adults tend to move through all four parts on their own. Younger kids may only do some of them, and usually only when someone prompts them. So a five year old who says thank you because you told her to isn't failing at gratitude, she's doing the do part with help.

The prompting matters. In Hussong's daily diary study, on days parents did more to cultivate gratitude, like talking with kids about something someone gave them, kids showed more gratitude that same day.

Between about 8 and 11, kids get better at holding the giver in mind. A school curriculum by Jeffrey Froh and colleagues taught kids three ideas: someone helped me on purpose, it cost them something, and it's valuable to me. Kids who participated in the daily curriculum version wrote 80% more thank you cards, and the weekly curriculum version kept kids more grateful five months later (Froh et al., 2014).

In early adolescence, simpler practices start to stick. Sixth and seventh graders who listed up to five things they were grateful for each day for two weeks felt more satisfied with school, right after and three weeks later (Froh, Sefick, & Emmons, 2008).


The kids who benefit most may surprise you

When Froh's team had kids and teens write and personally deliver a gratitude letter, the benefits showed up mostly in kids who were low in positive emotion to start, and they were still feeling more positive two months later (Froh et al., 2009). Gratitude isn't just a nice extra for kids who are already doing well. It may matter most for the kid who's having the hardest time.


The one question that makes "three good things" work

We do three good things at dinner in our house, borrowed from the Substack Tell Me 3 Good Things by Emily. It covers the notice part beautifully. The upgrade is adding a think question after one of them, like "Who made that happen?" or "Why do you think they did that?" That's the heart of Froh's curriculum in one sentence.

Watch for the list going stale, too. For my kids, stale is “I’m grateful for my mom, dad, sibling, and dog.” Froh has described "gratitude fatigue" as kids naming the same things every day, and the fix is specificity. Not "my dog," but "my dog sat with me when I was sad."

Rose, bud and thorn is a great practice, and in my experience it builds something different, the ability to hold a good part and a hard part of the same day. It becomes gratitude when someone asks the think question.


Gratitude is not the same as looking on the bright side

When gratitude gets used to skip past a hard feeling, kids learn that hard feelings need to be flipped fast. Researchers Kristin Layous and Sonja Lyubomirsky argued that gratitude likely only helps to the extent that it's authentic, and questioned whether making kids express it could backfire (Layous & Lyubomirsky, 2014). That's their prediction rather than a tested result, but it matches what I see in my own home and with the families I work with.

So the order I hold myself to is name the hard first, then look for the gift inside it. My car moment wasn't pretending the morning didn't suck. And the piece that will actually teach my daughter is letting her hear it, so when she gets home today I'm circling back with her, something as simple as "I was really glad I got to sit with you this morning." Then she gets to feel gratitude from the other side. Someone chose to stay.


What this looks like for your kid

Which part of gratitude is still coming online for your child, and why the same routine lands with one kid and falls flat with another, depends on your specific kid. That's what a free 30-minute discovery call is for.

By Lauren Greeno
Child & Adolescent Development Specialist & Parenting Coach | Founder, The Parenting Collaborative

Lauren specializes in helping parents understand invisible dynamics shaping their children’s development and redesigning family systems before patterns calcify into adult identity. With expertise in child development, family systems theory, and trauma-informed parenting, she works with families navigating sibling dynamics, only child considerations, neurodivergence, emotional regulation, and breaking generational patterns.

Work with Lauren: Book a discovery call | Learn more| Instagram | TikTok


References

Froh, J. J., Bono, G., Fan, J., Emmons, R. A., Henderson, K., Harris, C., Leggio, H., & Wood, A. M. (2014). Nice thinking! An educational intervention that teaches children to think gratefully. School Psychology Review, 43(2), 132–152. source

Froh, J. J., Kashdan, T. B., Ozimkowski, K. M., & Miller, N. (2009). Who benefits the most from a gratitude intervention in children and adolescents? Examining positive affect as a moderator. The Journal of Positive Psychology, 4(5), 408–422. source

Froh, J. J., Sefick, W. J., & Emmons, R. A. (2008). Counting blessings in early adolescents: An experimental study of gratitude and subjective well-being. Journal of School Psychology, 46(2), 213–233. source

Hussong, A. M., Langley, H. A., Rothenberg, W. A., Coffman, J. L., Halberstadt, A. G., Costanzo, P. R., & Mokrova, I. (2018). Raising grateful children one day at a time. Applied Developmental Science. source

Layous, K., & Lyubomirsky, S. (2014). Benefits, mechanisms, and new directions for teaching gratitude to children. School Psychology Review, 43(2). source

Supporting summaries: Greater Good in Education, Greater Good, "Grateful Schools, Happy Schools", Froh on gratitude fatigue (WSJ reprint)

Next
Next

How to Bond With Your Adopted Baby (or a Baby Born Through Surrogacy): What the Research Says